Alyssa Schukar
The general focus of these photographs is a woman's struggle with an eating disorder.
3 things the judges disliked:
- The 3rd photo was unoriginal, has been done better by other photographers.
- The photos are distanced, no emotions are immediately felt when looking at them.
- Each picture is very similar.
2 things the judges like:
- The photo of the Haitian man sweeping.
- The photo of the girl on the ground after falling over a hurdle.
I did not particularly like these photographs. To me, they felt very staged and unnatural.
Sam Adams
The general focus of these photographs is BMX biking.
3 things the judges disliked:
- The position of the helicopter in the silhouette photograph.
- Several photos did nothing artistically for the judges.
- The tilt of the photo of the far-away biker hanging in the air.
2 things the judges like:
- The B&W photograph of the boy on the bike coming down a tunnel.
- The photo of the priest hurrying through a hall.
I didn't like these photos much either. Many of them were the same, just bikers standing in an empty pool or something. Also, a lot of them were just random photos that did not follow any rules of photography.
Justin Mott
The general focus of these photos is a few different groups of people and their lives.
3 things the judges disliked:
- On the photograph looking down a line of soldiers towards another one, their eyes were led to nothing interesting.
- There was a major lack of focus in many photos.
- There were unsuccessful tries at graphics.
2 things the judges like:
- The photograph of the starving boy in the beginning.
- The photograph of the dead pig.
I really liked these photographs. On some of the photos, the unfocused-ness was very beautiful. The photos told stories and I love that they were in B&W.
Dustin Snipes
The judges noted that he was good at capturing movement, getting in with the action, and finding/photographing emotion.
Some of his strengths that I see are the interesting angles and colors he had in his photographs. A weakness I saw was that sometimes there were little things that could have been changed in the position of the photo that would have made it better.
In deciding the winner, the judges:
- Noted what they did and did not like
- Found strengths and weaknesses in each photographer
- Came to a general agreement on who the winner should be
PART 2
One photo I agree with the judges on is the photo of boxing. I agree with them on the topic of distraction, the light on the man's shoulder threw me off a bit.
One photo I don't agree with the judges on is the photo of the girl jumping in the air. I thought it was a pretty fun looking shot.